Shelter Island’s celebrity mansion gets a huge price cut
Louis C.K.’s historic Shelter Island home just hit the market again—this time for $4.3 million, less than half its original $9.25 million price tag. This isn’t just any house: it’s a 1901 Tudor that once hosted President McKinley, Theodore Roosevelt, and even inspired “Peter Pan.” Louis spent a decade blending old-world charm with modern luxury, adding a pool, hot tub, and restoring original details. With over 5,000 square feet, waterfront views, and a private dock, it’s a rare slice of American history. Would you want to live in a place with this much story?
#RealEstate #ShelterIsland #HistoricHomes
