Generations of Brooklynites have quietly kept Defonte’s Sandwich Shop in Red Hook at the top of their must-eat list. While tourists flock to Manhattan’s flashy delis, true New Yorkers know the real deal is tucked away on a quiet corner, serving up overstuffed Italian heroes just like they did in 1922. The shop’s no-frills vibe, century-old recipes, and family-run warmth make every visit feel like stepping into living food history. Have you made the trek for a Nicky Special yet? What’s your go-to NYC sandwich spot that deserves more love? #Food #BrooklynEats #HiddenGems