Gone Girls: The Long Island Serial Killer just snagged the #1 spot on Variety’s 2025 true crime doc list, beating out the viral Unknown Number: The High School Catfish. The real twist? Fans are divided—some say Gone Girls deserved it for its victim-focused storytelling, while others argue Catfish’s insane reveal was robbed. Are we finally over plot twists, or do critics just love a good community angle? #Entertainment #Movies #TrueCrime